By Terry Moore and Matt Saunders
In early November, we presented When Things Go Wrong: Reputational Risk and Crisis Readiness for Law Firms at the 2026 LMA Canada Conference. The timing provided an uncomfortable reminder of why this conversation matters.
Just prior to the conference, four major Canadian law firms reported data breaches.[1] The Canadian Centre for Cyber Security also warned of an active campaign in which attackers impersonated internal IT support and directed employees to fraudulent sign-in pages.
Less than two weeks later, a global Microsoft outage disrupted Outlook, Teams and other Office 365 services. Microsoft blamed server issues, rather than malicious activity.[2]
The incidents were different, but the lesson was the same: no organization is immune from disruption. A law firm may be targeted directly, negatively impacted by a technology provider suffering from an outage, or is unable to operate because of a critical infrastructure failure, extreme weather event, or other emergency beyond its control.
What firms can control is their preparation and response.
A crisis quickly becomes a firm-wide issue
During our session, we explored three different scenarios: a ransomware incident, a case of trust-account misconduct, and a major flooding event. Each crisis had a different trigger, but the pressure landed in many of the same places: service and staff disruption, lost productivity, client concerns, regulatory obligations, significant media attention, and reputational harm.
Whatever the source of the disruption, its effects rarely remain confined within a single part of the firm. Operational decisions can affect clients, employees and other stakeholders, while early choices about what to do, who to involve, and how to communicate can have lasting (and potentially negative) consequences. An effective response plan depends on bringing the right perspectives together quickly, with clear roles and established channels for escalation.
Our opening audience poll reinforced the breadth of the challenge. Cyber incidents were clearly top of mind, but results also pointed to cases of professional misconduct, regulatory investigations, and reputational harm arising from client matters playing out in the press. The triggers may be different, but the underlying challenge is often the same: making good decisions under pressure, coordinating the right people, and protecting trust while the facts are still emerging.
The first questions are often the simplest
Our tabletop ransomware exercise asked participants to work a series of facts specific to the first hour, the next 2-4 hours, and the remainder of Day 1 of the incident. Rather than trying to solve the entire crisis, we asked three questions:
· What do we know?
· What don't we know?
· Who or what can help?
These questions force discipline when information is incomplete and the pressure to act is high. They help teams distinguish facts from assumptions, identify gaps, and bring the right people into the response. They also help to avoid making decisions that may compromise evidence preservation, legal obligations, recovery efforts, or stakeholder trust.
Readiness is everyone’s responsibility
So where should firms start? Not by trying to anticipate every possible crisis, but by building the team, processes, and relationships that will help them respond effectively when something goes wrong.
Preparation should include clear decision-making authority and escalation procedures, tested off-site backups and continuity plans, a consideration of relevant insurance policies, pre-arranged external advisers, and protocols for communicating with employees, clients, regulators, and the media.
A plan on paper is not enough. Teams need to understand their roles, know who has authority to make key decisions, understand where verified information will be maintained, and be prepared to act without waiting for a complete picture.
One practical way to test that readiness is through a tabletop exercise. Working through a realistic scenario in a low-risk environment can reveal planning strengths (and weaknesses), clarify roles, and give teams the opportunity to experience making difficult (albeit fictional) decisions before they have to make them in real life.
We cannot predict every event or prevent every disruption. Readiness means building the capacity to make good decisions under pressure and facing uncertainty, while maintaining the confidence of clients, employees, and other stakeholders. An incident may take us by surprise, but its possibility should not.
For firms looking to strengthen their own preparedness, we have included additional resources covering crisis planning and response, cybersecurity, privacy, and other areas relevant to law firm risk and resilience.
Additional resources
· Government of Canada. Get Cyber Safe; available online: https://www.getcybersafe.gc.ca/en
· Government of Canada. Emergency Preparedness; available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/services/policing/emergencies/preparedness.html
· Government of Canada. Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre; available online: https://antifraudcentre-centreantifraude.ca/index-eng.htm
· Communications Security Establishment. Canadian Centre for Cyber Security; available online: https://www.cyber.gc.ca/en
· Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. Resources and References; available online: https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/
[1] “Canadian law firms see increased cyberattacks, data breaches”, ABA Journal (2 November 2026), online: <https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/canadian-law-firms-seeing-increased-cyber-attacks-and-data-breaches>.
[2] “Microsoft services fully restored after global outage”, CBC News (14 November 2026), online: <https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/microsoft-services-restored-after-outage-9.7422072>;